A final ruling from the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York restores protections for people attending immigration court. The September 30, 2026 decision in African Communities Together and The Door v. Todd Lyons bars ICE from conducting civil immigration enforcement actions in or near immigration courthouses except under limited circumstances. The ruling applies nationwide, including in New York City, and is effective immediately.
The court found the challenged policy “arbitrary and capricious” under the Administrative Procedure Act. It set aside the portions of ICE’s 2025 guidance that rescinded earlier restrictions on enforcement at immigration courts, restoring the pre-existing safeguards that permit courthouse arrests only in rare circumstances.
The lawsuit also challenged a related 2025 Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) policy that encouraged immigration judges to dismiss proceedings without proper procedural protections. The court dismissed that claim as moot because the government had fully and permanently withdrawn the policy following an earlier order in the case.
The decision follows Pablo Sequen v. Albarran, a separate case involving the ACLU of Northern California that also struck down the administration’s courthouse arrest policy nationwide.
Since President Trump took office, ICE has arrested people attending required immigration hearings and sought to accelerate their deportation. Those affected include Dylan, a 16-year-old Bronx high school student arrested at a routine court appearance, and Oliver Mata Velazquez, a 19-year-old Buffalo resident who was targeted, detained, and placed on a fast track toward deportation.
The organizations bringing the case described encounters involving masked, sometimes armed officers, including people being thrown to the ground and children separated from their parents. They emphasized the dilemma courthouse arrests created: attending a required hearing could lead to detention, while failing to appear could result in a deportation order.
The ruling restores safeguards that support meaningful access to court and reinforces the requirement that agencies provide a reasoned explanation before abandoning existing protections. The organizations said their focus now turns to ensuring government compliance with the decision.
For questions about your immigration court case, contact us at 212-233-8100 to schedule a consultation.
Note: This article provides general information and is not legal advice.
Source: New York Civil Liberties Union. Read the court’s decision.